Murphy's Law: Risky Business

Archives

November 1, 2008: Only two weeks after announcing it, Malaysia is cancelling the purchase of a dozen Eurocopter Cougar EC725 helicopters. The main reason is the current threat of a world-wide recession. Another, less discussed reason, were recent accusations that bribes were paid to make the sale.

This will delay, by a year or two, efforts to begin replacing the 40 elderly Sea King helicopters Malaysia currently uses. These are actually British built (under license) U.S. S-61s. The nine ton Sea King is a late 1950s design, and contemporary of the U.S. Army's UH-1 "Huey." In the U.S., the Sea Kings were replaced by a navy version of the Hueys successor, the UH-60 Blackhawk. Over a dozen other navies bought the Sea King, and many still use it. But these aircraft are getting old.

The Sea King has a range of about a thousand kilometers, and a top speed of 210 kilometers an hour. It was mainly used for anti-submarine warfare and search and rescue. Some 1,500 were built (about ten percent were the civilian S-61 version), and over a hundred are still in use. Such long service lives are increasingly common. Some of the first Sea Kings survived for over three decades.

The Eurocopter Cougar EC725 is an 11 ton aircraft with a useful load of 5.5 tons, a top speed of 324 kilometers an hour, a range of about 850 kilometers and can stay in the air for about five hours per sortie. This makes them excellent replacements for the elderly Sea Kings. Malaysia was going to pay about $50 million for each Cougar, which training, tech support, a supply of spare parts and some bribes.